Do you also want to invest in the stock market but are not able to understand whether short-term trading or long-term trading is right for you? No problem, we are here to explain!
Imagine you have ₹ 10,000. One way is to earn small profits by catching the daily market movement (which is called day trading or swing trading). The other way is to invest that money in a good stock for a long time and let its value increase with time. This is the real battle of trading vs. investing.
However, the difference between these two methods is not just about time. Your mindset, risk-taking ability, and financial goals also play an important role in this. And the most important thing – can you stare at the charts all day, or would you like to see the statement just once a month?
In this article, we will understand what the difference is between short-term trading and long-term trading, how much risk is involved in each (stock market investment risks), and which method you should adopt. Along with this, you will get some real data and easy examples so that you can choose your investment path without any hesitation.
Now let’s know in depth about this exciting world – trading vs investing!
When you enter the stock market, the first thing you need to think about is – how much time do you want to give and how much risk can you take? The answer to this question decides whether short-term trading is right for you or long-term trading.
Both have their own fun, but the world of both is completely different. Let us first understand what these two words actually mean.
Short-term trading means trading in which you buy and sell shares in a few minutes, hours, or days. The goal of earning profit in this is quick, so one has to be very active in it.
Time Horizon: In this, the trading time is very short – from a few minutes to a few weeks. Here there are fewer investors and more active traders.
Day Trading: In this, shares are bought and sold on the same day. Trades can be done several times in a day. For this type of trading, a keen eye on the market movement is necessary.
Swing Trading: In this, traders hold shares for a few days to a few weeks. These people make profits from small fluctuations in the market.
Scalping: In this, dozens of trades are done in a few minutes. Overall, good money is made from small profits. This can also be a part of high-frequency trading.
People doing this type of trading have to take quick decisions and spend more time on the computer screen. It can also be stressful, but for many people it is like an adrenalin rush.
Long-term trading or investing, means you hold the stock for several months or years. In this, your objective is to increase the value of your investment along with the growth of the company.
Holding Period: The investment period can be from a minimum of 1 year to 10–15 years or even more. There is no need to watch the market daily – patience is the biggest weapon.
Buy-and-Hold Investing: In this, investors buy shares of companies with good fundamentals and hold them for a long time. Like you bought a share of ₹500 today, and it became ₹5000 in 10 years.
Value Investing: In this, those companies are selected whose market price is less than their real value. That is, they are underrated right now, but they will shine in the future. Warren Buffett is considered the master of this strategy.
This type of trading is best for those who want to grow wealth peacefully for a long time and like to stay away from the daily hustle and bustle of the market.
Now that we understand both – short-term trading is fast, risky but exciting, whereas long-term trading is steady, patient and shows the magic of compounding.
Now that we have understood these two trading styles, let’s know the important points that make the real difference between short-term trading and long-term trading.
Capital Requirements
Short-term trading often requires more capital to make quick profits. Especially if you do day trading or swing trading, you need a good amount of money for broking, taxes and maintaining the position.
On the other hand, long-term trading or investing can also start with small capital. You can gradually build wealth by investing for a long period in SIPs, mutual funds or small shares.
That is, short-term trading requires more capital, while long-term investing is possible even with less capital.
Time Commitment
Short-term trading is like a full-time job. You have to keep an eye on the market movement every minute and track charts and news. It requires an active mindset.
Long-term trading, on the other hand, is a passive approach. Once you invest in a good stock, you do not need to monitor it daily.
For those who cannot give time to the market, long-term trading is a better option.
Risk and Volatility
Short-term traders have to bear the brunt of even small market movements. A wrong decision can lead to losses, as this is a high-volatility zone.
Long-term traders have time to recover things. Even if the market falls, there is a higher chance of improvement in the long term. Therefore, here the risk can be balanced with time.
So if you are afraid of volatility, then long-term investing may be safer for you.
Profits can be high in short-term trading, but they are also volatile and uncertain. If the risk is high, the gains can also be high – but losses are equally possible.
In long-term investing, returns are slow, but the effect of compounding is profound. If you have invested in the right company, that investment can grow manifold in 5 to 10 years.
If you have high risk-taking ability, then short-term is best; otherwise, long-term is best for safe and stable returns.
In short-term trading, everyday stress, taking quick decisions, and bearing losses – all these can be mentally tiring. Many times, wrong decisions are made by getting carried away by emotions.
Patience and discipline are required in long-term investing. Emotions play a lesser role here because decisions are taken over months or years.
If you panic easily or have no control over your emotions, then long-term trading may be better for your mental peace.
To summarise, short-term trading can be active and risky but can give fast profits. On the other hand, long-term trading is a game of patience, consistency and compounding, where your money matures with time.
Short-term trading is not just one method; it is a combination of several strategies. Each trader has his own unique style, and here we will talk about the three most commonly used short-term trading techniques: day trading, swing trading and scalping.
Day trading means buying and selling shares within the same day. Its purpose is to make a profit from small fluctuations throughout the day. Suppose you bought a stock for ₹ 200 in the morning and sold it for ₹ 210 in the afternoon – this is the daily profit.
How to make a profit:
Day traders usually trade in a few hours or minutes. In this, they monitor the stocks in which there is rapid movement.
Tools used:
Candlestick charts
Moving Averages (MA)
Relative Strength Index (RSI)
Volume indicators
With the help of all these, day traders decide when to enter and when to exit.
Swing trading is for those who want to give a little time but do not want to stick to the screen every day. In this, you hold a stock for 3 days to 2 weeks and earn profit by looking at its price movement.
How it works:
Traders identify with technical analysis which stock can go up or down in the coming days and create positions accordingly.
Technical Strategies:
Support & resistance zones
Fibonacci retracements
Trend lines
MACD (Moving Average Convergence Divergence)
Scalping
Scalping is the fastest form of trading. In this, traders make multiple small trades within a few seconds or minutes and accumulate small profits.
The profit margin here is very low, but the number of trades is high. Therefore, discipline and speed are extremely important.
Techniques used:
1-minute or 5-minute charts
Order book and bid-ask spread analysis
High-Frequency Trading (HFT) and Algo Trading Strategies
Overall, if you have the time and experience, these short-term trading strategies can be great. But every strategy comes with risk, so proper knowledge and planning are important.
If you don’t want the daily hassle of trading and want to grow money slowly for the future, then long-term trading is a better option for you. This strategy is based on low risk, more stability and the magic of compounding.
Here we will talk about the three most popular long-term strategies – value investing, growth investing, and dividend investing.
Value investing means investing in companies whose real value is undervalued in the market. That is, the company is strong, but the stock is currently available at a low price.
How it works:
You choose stocks that are undervalued – that is, whose value should be higher according to their financials, assets and growth.
Warren Buffett’s formula:
The world’s most successful investor, Warren Buffett, follows this strategy. He believes that “Invest in the best companies when others are ignoring them due to fear.”
Growth Investing
In growth investing, you invest in companies that can grow rapidly in the future such as companies in the technology, e-commerce or health tech sectors.
If you choose the right growth company at the right time, your investment can multiply manifold.
There is also risk:
Growth stocks have high volatility, and sometimes the company’s growth is not as expected. Therefore, the risk is a little higher.
Dividend Investing
In dividend investing, you invest in companies that give a part of their profit to investors every year in the form of dividends.
What is the benefit of this:
You not only get income from the increase in share price but also get a fixed income every year like a pension.
Best Sectors:
FMCG (like HUL, Nestlé)
Banking and Insurance
Energy and Utilities (like NTPC, PowerGrid)
If you are a long-distance runner and believe in “go slow, go far”, these long-term strategies can form the foundation of your financial growth.
Which Approach Is Better for You?
So far, we have seen that short-term trading is based on a fast-paced and active approach, while long-term investing is based on patience and time. But the question is – which strategy is best for you? The answer lies in your investment goals, risk tolerance and time availability.
Overtrading
Overtrading means trading repeatedly without need. Many new day traders and swing traders think that the more trades they make, the more profit they will earn. But often the opposite happens. Every time you trade, you have to pay brokerage and bear emotional stress. Remember, quality is more important in trading, not quantity.
Which trading style is more profitable in the long run?
If you are patient and want to grow your money slowly, then there is nothing better than long-term investing. When you invest with faith in good companies and give them time, that money keeps growing on its own. Yes, some people do short-term trading for quick profits, but the risk there is also equally high.
How do I decide between short-term and long-term trading?
Just ask yourself – do you have time to watch the market every day? Can you make quick decisions? If yes, then short-term trading may be right for you. But if you want to invest calmly and prefer to stay away from the hustle and bustle of the market, then long-term investing will be more appropriate.
What are the risks of day trading?
Day trading has very high fluctuations. It can:
Can I combine short-term and long-term trading strategies?
Of course you can. Many smart investors do this – they invest the money they earn from small deals in long-term investments. This not only gives some quick profit, but also prepares for stable growth in the future. But remember, adopt both the approaches only after understanding them; do not be hasty.
The programs at Learnovation empower the students to crack the vagaries of the Stock Market. Expert insights by industry leaders at Learnovation guide them every step to becoming top performers.
